Seven out of ten overall, and thats generous for the stretch between Geordie Bay and the lighthouse. The Rottnest Island bike loop gets talked up as one of the great WA rides, and for the first half that reputation holds. The back half is where people underestimate it, usually because they've only seen photos of the Basin on a flat calm day.

The full loop runs close to 22 kilometres if you ride the perimeter road properly, out past the Basin, around through the west end settlements and back along the southern coast. It's not a hard ride by distance. It's hard by wind, heat and a handful of genuine climbs that catch people on hire bikes with no gears left to drop into.

What the loop actually asks of you

Sealed road for most of it, with gravel shoulders and a few patches where the bitumen has given up near the salt lakes. The surface quality drops noticeably once you're past Parker Point heading toward the west end — expect corrugations, loose gravel on the corners, and the odd pothole that'll rattle a hire bike's rack loose if it's already a bit tired. I run the gravel bike at around 45-50 psi for this loop, a touch softer than I'd use on bitumen back in Perth, because the extra give helps on the rougher sections without making the sealed stretches feel sluggish.

Wind is the other factor nobody mentions until they're fighting it. Rottnest sits exposed, and a sou'wester in the afternoon turns an easy ride into genuine work on the open stretches near the airport and the salt lakes. Mornings are calmer, full stop.

Settlement to the north end: the easy kays

From the Settlement out past Longreach Bay and Geordie Bay the riding is gentle — rolling, sealed, well shaded in parts. This is where most day-trippers do their loop and call it done, and honestly it's a fine ride if that's all the time you've got. Traffic is mostly other cyclists and the occasional shuttle bus, nothing that'll rattle you.

It's also the busiest section by a wide margin, especially around the Basin where everyone stops for a swim. If you're after a cleaner first-timer rundown of what the ferry and hire options actually cost before you commit to a full day on the island, the Rottnest tour packages compared: ferry, bike hire and extras piece covers that ground properly — worth a read before you book anything.

The west end: where the Rottnest Island bike loop earns its rating

Past Fairbridge Bungalow the road tightens and climbs. Nothing alpine, but enough rise near the lighthouse and around to Cathedral Rocks that a flat-bar hire bike with three gears will have you standing on the pedals. This is the section that separates people who rode it once and loved the idea of it from people who actually finished the loop.

I reckon this stretch is flat out the pick of the whole island if you're after a proper ride rather than a cruise — the coastline opens up, there's barely anyone out there compared to the Basin crush, and the gradient actually makes you work for the view. It's also where I'd push back a bit on the island's